The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society: From Text to Screen


For bibliophiles, a book about books, authors and reading clubs is nothing less than sheer delight. And the Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society is exactly that. Mary Ann Shaffer’s first and only book is based in the London of 1946 and post occupation Guernsey of the Channel islands.

The title is nothing but uncanny for a book and now a motion picture. Juliet Ashton is an upcoming author who wrote Izzy Bickerstaff Goes to War. While her book was doing well and she was doing readings across England, she was keenly looking for new subject to write on. It was then that she gets a letter from one Dawsey Adams of Guernsey.

Dawsey came across a book by Charles Lamb which it seems belonged to Juliet. Finding her address on the book, he wrote to her requesting her to send him some more of Charles Lamb’s works. Dawsey in one of his letters talked about the Guernsey Literary Society. The name stuck Ashton and she got curious.

This was followed by a detailed interaction with other members of the literary society. The entire book is written in the form of letters. It unfolds that the Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society was the spontaneous creation of Elizabeth McKenna when their small group was apprehended by German soldiers. They had to find an excuse as they were visiting Amelia Maugery and eating a roasted pig which was hidden away from the German soldiers.

But with time the literary society acquired reality and it was their book club meetings and reading which helped them get through the difficult period of the occupation. When Ashton moved to Guernsey to know more about the club and write about it, she discovered more about the book club members and their days under the occupation.

Guernsey was allegedly to be made a model occupied territory where the locals were supposed to live alongside the soldiers. But wars are difficult time to survive. While many amongst the Germans were also wary of the war, the soldiers at times had problems with the locals – especially when they took away all the food and livestock. Elizabeth got involved with a German soldier and had a baby. But she was caught helping one of the workers who deserted the Germans and was send to the concentration camps.

With no news of Elizabeth, her daughter Kit grew up in the loving company of Elizabeth’s friends and they awaited Elizabeth’s return. But what came was a long letter from Remy, someone who stayed with Elizabeth at the Ravensbruck concentration camp. Remy wrote that even in the camp she stood up for what she believed.

In concentration camps, women were not given sanitary napkins while menstruating. Blood run through their legs and soldiers would harass them for such mess. Elizabeth was shot when she stood up to a soldier beating up a menstruating girl. While Juliet moved to the tiny island for a story, she found much more in it.

The movie tried to do justice to the story. While the original storyline was kept more or less same, there were plot lines and characters left out. Remy’s character was left out and how Elizabeth died was kept vague. While movie length requires editing, keeping this would have made the movie as good as the book.

Both the movie and the book told beautiful stories and tried to bring home the joy of reading even amidst the harsh realities of a war torn society.

Post a Comment

0 Comments